The Prep Mock Trial team won the 2004 - 2005 District Title at the William J. Nealon Federal Courthouse in Scranton. Team members who acted as lawyers and witnesses were:
seniors, Molly O'Brien, Layla Tabatabaie and John Rizzo;
juniors, Elizabeth Burke, Kathryn Burke, Ryan Lynady and Mark Kania;
and sophomore, Jason Mannion.

Prep will advance to the regional competition against Marian Catholic High School, Tamaqua.

Prep's Mock Trial Team placed second in the state championships out of 270 participating teams. The group of eight students argued a mock case about a fan killed at a rock concert. The victim's family sued the star, claiming she incited a riot. In Mock Trial competition, each time a team advances, it switches from plaintiff to defense. The competition, held in the State Senate Chambers, is sponsored by the Pennsylvania Bar Association. The students who argued the case were: Elizabeth Burke, Katie Burke, Mark Kania, Ryan Lynady, Jason Mannion, Molly O'Brien, John Rizzo, and Layla Tabatabaie. Judge Malachy Mannion and Attorney John O'Brien are team advisors.

Mrs. Mary Grace Phillips is the moderator.